Utada Net.com Forum Index
   General Utada Discussion
  Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?

 

 Bottom   Previous Topic   Next Topic
<12345>
  •  Topic options
Poster Thread
  •  Idle_mind
      Idle_mind
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/8/28
A/S/L In my infinite universe
Posts: 588
Definitely Simple and Clean. Sanctuary just sounded so bad compared to Passion in the KH2 intro. As for Hikari or Passion, Passion of course. Hikki originally wrote the songs in Japanese, so of course they'll sound better in that language.
_________________
Deus ex Machina
Posted on: 2007/12/19 1:56
Top
  •  Idle_mind
      Idle_mind
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/8/28
A/S/L In my infinite universe
Posts: 588
Hikki lengthens the words in Sanctuary to match the melody. For example, in Passion it's "haruka haruka" while in Sanctuary it's "there's a new land". It makes the song sound unnatural.
_________________
Deus ex Machina
Posted on: 2007/12/19 2:15
Top
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/5/15
A/S/L 23/F/RSA
Posts: 368
Simple and Clean is definately better, but i do like sanctuary's sweet lyrics and tune.

I think S&C is better because she changed the chorus tune to the "uso mitai na I love you" tune, which was a really good idea, don't think it wouldv sounded good if she used the Hikari tune...

i also didn't like the fact that Sanctuary was missing the background vocals like the ones from Passion, Passion sounds so much better, even the music is more "vivid", i mean you can hear the drum beats pretty clear, like heavy...but in sanctuary it was all mild and soft...
_________________
Posted on: 2007/12/19 7:07
Top
  •  <3_UtadaHikaru_Aijin_<3
      <3_UtadaHikaru_Aijin_<3
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Show Off!
Joined: 2007/7/24
A/S/L 17/M/Cal
Posts: 8413
i've said this once and i will say it again

awesome siggy there angel, love the effect
_________________
Posted on: 2007/12/19 11:42
Top
  •  hrabbit
      hrabbit
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/12/15
A/S/L ??/female/USA
Posts: 391
Simple and clean~ hands down. I didn't attatch too much too sanctuary
Posted on: 2007/12/19 12:55
Top
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/5/15
A/S/L 23/F/RSA
Posts: 368
Thanx Aijin
_________________
Posted on: 2007/12/20 7:43
Top
  •  <3_UtadaHikaru_Aijin_<3
      <3_UtadaHikaru_Aijin_<3
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Show Off!
Joined: 2007/7/24
A/S/L 17/M/Cal
Posts: 8413
NP (^_^)
_________________
Posted on: 2007/12/20 15:12
Top
  •  jigenbakuda
      jigenbakuda
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/9/30
A/S/L 23/M/Jacksonville FL
Posts: 417
lol, I'm probably the only person on here that doesn't associate her with one of these 2 songs. I really never listened to either of them... Oh course passion is one of my favorite songs by her, but I haven't heard sanctuary enough to make a comparison. So simple and clean wins by default. I had a vid of her singing it in here home studio, or whatever, maybe it was live, but anyways, I liked simple and clean.
_________________

If one sets a trap, isn't it the victim's fault for falling in?
Posted on: 2007/12/20 16:48
Top
  •  lildragon91
      lildragon91
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Hikki Fanatic
Joined: 2006/1/10
A/S/L 16/M/Aus
Posts: 111
simple and clean for sure!
but if it was passion and hikari it wood be close but i would pick hikari, i just love that song
Posted on: 2008/1/2 0:01
Top
Re: Which Song Is Better Simple and Clean or Sanctuary?
Moderator
Joined: 2007/12/30
A/S/L 20 / F / Manila, Philippines
Posts: 3074
for me simple and clean is nicer than sanctuary, actually i like it both. it's just that, I somehow don't like some lyrics and attachments of sanctuary. but both sounds good and sounds great in japanese
_________________

Utada Hikaru made my day on October 24, 2010 at exactly 6pm (Philippine time)
Posted on: 2008/1/2 6:15
Top
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic
<12345>