I saw this game on many forums, and thought it could work here. Rules are simple: there's a list with songs' titles. Every song gets 30 points. Everyone chooses the best song and adds 2 points to it (SAVE). Then he chooses the worst song and takes 2 points from it (KILL). For example:

Hikari 30
Passion 30
B&C 28 KILL
First Love 30
Beautiful World 32 SAVE

Song with 60 points goes to HALL OF FAME. Song with 0 points goes to HALL OF SHAME. When a song gets either 60 or 0 points, you can't vote for it anymore and you can write another song with 30 points. I hope it's clear.

So, let's start with earlier singles:

Movin' On Without You 30
Automatic 30
First Love 30
For You 30
Can You Keep a Secret? 30
Addicted to You 30
Wait & See (Risk) 30
Kettobase! 32 SAVE
Time Limit 30
Time Will Tell 28 KILL