Quote:
Macdan wrote:
Quote:
SwallowTail wrote:
Actually i have different perspective with you guys, this time i agree with laijunjie14 i agree with Alexfenway words .
I want to comment as Hikki fans not as a mod. Alexfenway got a point even though he using a harsh word, but its still he still polite. A fans job not just to support but also to scold if she do a bad move, because Hikki were nothing without a fans don't you think .
How long you guys be a fans you of Utada and why? and me
because her song lyric
If you look at her Japanese song, take a look at Flavor of Life, Deep River , Hikari, Passion , Keep Tryin and many more . Can you find song like that in US music industry and got famous . I don't think so, but correct me if was wrong and give me what song .
This time Hikki or Utada in US only follow what happen in US music industry or should i say she being a chameleon , Hikki have a lot of talent and if and you want to be famous in US follow their rules. Hikki have a lot of fans all over the world , who cares about those corporate CEO. Hikki doesn't need to make a cheezy song she mostly TITO song make her look cheezy. Find a really good song in TITO and compared that to her Heart Station and which one can make you happy if you got sad like "Fight the Blues".
Last yeah Alexfenway you got guts to doing it, i dont know if i got guts and hope Hikki read it and understand why you doing it.
There you go my opinion
I actually kinda supports what SwallowTail has said, like Alexfenway is just expressing his opinions but just using harsh words. I also agree that being a fan is not just to support blindly, but also giving opinions and suggestions. I believe that Utada thinks that even though that Alexfenway is using harsh words, she can see the meaning behind those harsh texts.
I also feel that there's difference in her Japanese work and English Work, so maybe SwallowTail is right in saying that Utada has to "follow the rules" in the US music industry, kinda like "blend in" and get recognized, maybe. So I think I understand why the difference.
As for saying Alexfenway has got guts in doing such comment, I think he do have the guts, because I believe that when someone do such comment, whether he/she is a fan or not, they will be treated as a Troll or Basher. Most of the fans just leave positive comments like "good job" or "well done", rather than leaving comments like suggestions on how to make it better. So I do think that Alexfenway is not just plainly bashing Utada, but giving suggestion and opinion, in a harsh manner. I am sure Utada will not mind the words and take note of the opinion, she might even think that it is a useful opinion.
Perfectly natural, right and fair, to voice and share an opinion, there is no debate there, we can argue passionately with ?bells on? use harsh criticism, but when a person uses language like scum and it meaning (One, such as a person or an element of society, that is regarded as despicable or worthless) ,
Not harsh words, just hurtful and offensive.
The question has never been about Akexfenway, whether in agreement or disagreement, it has been about treating Hikki with respect .