Utada Net.com Forum Index
   Utada News
   Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
Poster Thread
Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded
Hikki Obsessed
Joined: 2007/2/10
A/S/L 18/GQ?/CA
Posts: 431
Quote:

山本_passion wrote:
Well...to be blunt, I'm almost entirely sure they fixed up her entire performance. Listen to the wild life goodbye happiness, where she first starts singing "Love me", then compare it to when she actually sang it. for me that was the sign it was fixed.

I don't hear it. I just watched the two videos in tandem and it is exactly the same note (try singing along with her if you can follow music and listen to yourself; did the note you sang change?). It hasn't been pitch corrected at all; it simply sounds infinitely better because the audio quality is infinitely better (also some of the refortifying echo from it was captured on the DVD quality video that was simply absent from the live stream). That goes for the whole song. The official DVD will depict more of the natural depth and character of her voice than the live stream ever did, and that's going to give you an entirely different perspective on her performance.

Quote:

Chris85 wrote:
Actually they did such an awesome job. There were tons of off-key notes and they managed to fix them in a beautiful way. It's so clear when you watch TV-version of the whole concert or this cut. It's kinda sad that you can't hear such a significant change.

There are still plenty of flat or strained notes (0:43, 1:03, 1:08, 1:51, I could go on, but you'll notice this aligns exactly with the original broadcast if you care to compare...) and her characteristic dipping, meandering singing style persists. I don't really see how you can call it a significant change if there isn't a significant difference. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, of course, but I'm kind of confused as to how people aren't hearing the imperfect notes in the official video considering that they are even more obvious than they were before given the audio quality. :/

Quote:

hikaruomega wrote:
did they use the first cocert's audio or the second concert's audio? i think they used the second concert and that's why it sounds different.

Almost certainly the first. I suppose it's possible they interchanged certain segments from one night to the other, but the DVD video parallels the live stream musically from start to finish, so I don't think that's the case.
_________________
Posted on: 2011/3/5 20:12
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded illastrate 2011/2/27 20:55
     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Q 2011/2/27 21:02
     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Josh_Shing 2011/2/27 21:59
       Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded sokuri 2011/2/28 4:35
         Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded zunecrazy 2011/2/28 18:20
           Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Unregistered 2011/3/1 7:21
             Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded soulhunter14 2011/3/1 8:08
               Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Shurikid 2011/3/3 16:13
                 Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded 山本_passion 2011/3/3 16:51
                 Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Chris85 2011/3/5 4:48
                   Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Pips_Paradise 2011/3/5 9:15
                     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded hikaruomega 2011/3/5 19:57
                       Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded cube 2011/3/5 20:24
                   Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Shurikid 2011/3/5 20:12
                     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded 山本_passion 2011/3/5 21:29
                       Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Shurikid 2011/3/6 0:39
                         Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Chris85 2011/3/6 4:08
                           Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Shurikid 2011/3/6 19:07
                             Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Chris85 2011/3/6 19:28
                               Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Shurikid 2011/3/6 23:53
                                 Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Chris85 2011/3/7 2:16
                               Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded yvliew 2011/3/7 18:36
     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded cube 2011/3/6 20:04
       Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Chris85 2011/3/6 20:40
       Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded brunangii 2011/3/6 20:48
         Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded cube 2011/3/6 22:06
           Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded brunangii 2011/3/7 5:07
             Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded cube 2011/3/7 14:04
               Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded brunangii 2011/3/7 20:05
     Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded Josh_Shing 2011/3/7 20:52
       Re: Goodbye Happiness live version uploaded yvliew 2011/3/8 3:54
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic